Tuesday, July 24, 2012

PUNISHING THE WRONG PEOPLE

I can't seem to stop comparing the Penn State abuse scandal to the pedophilia horrors that plagued and continue to plague my Catholic Church.
Once again, young boys were victimized by someone they knew and trusted, and once again the perpetrator was the Goliath of a huge and intimidating organization. While the Church had a twisted pattern of simply transferring the guilty person to a new venue, Jerry Sandusky was left to pursue his prey until someone finally took action and the criminal activity was stopped. When some of the victims in the church scandal began to speak...many weren't believed, and many others never saw their perpetrators punished, as the evil moved to fresh hunting grounds.

When Cardinal Law in Boston had exhausted his options after years and years of inaction involving priests in his jurisdiction, he was sent to a new cushy assignment in Rome. At least everyone involved at Penn State is likely to suffer the consequences of his or her inaction. The similarities to the Catholic Church stop there.

I understand the fines...which are probably about what a year of football revenues amount to, and I understand the depth of the investigation and fair trial of anyone who was complicit, but ending the careers of many of the team members seems like punishing the congregation in the pews for what their priest did to the kids. The attempt to change history by erasing past victories seems a little like annulling any marriages or other sacraments performed while Father X was running the parish. Shaming the football team for what the coaches did or didn't do would be like making the Rosary Society and the Knights of Columbus wear scarlet letters to Mass.

Punish the culprits...take the pound of flesh, but remember not to give the whole class detention because little Joey didn't finish his seatwork. The good parishioners and priests who were also tainted by scandals all over the world will suffer enough for sins they didn't commit, and Penn State students and alumni have already had their college experience tarnished. There doesn't seem to be much mercy being dolled out for the innocent bystanders at State College this week.

No comments:

Post a Comment